Tortoise Media Archives - Press Gazette https://pressgazette.co.uk/subject/tortoise-media/ The Future of Media Tue, 26 Nov 2024 10:36:30 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.6.1 https://pressgazette.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/7/2022/09/cropped-Press-Gazette_favicon-32x32.jpg Tortoise Media Archives - Press Gazette https://pressgazette.co.uk/subject/tortoise-media/ 32 32 Scott Trust says ‘talks continue to progress’ over Observer sale to Tortoise https://pressgazette.co.uk/publishers/nationals/scott-trust-meeting-tortoise-observer/ Tue, 26 Nov 2024 10:36:25 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=234315 A picture of the offices of The Guardian and Observer, illustrating a story about voluntary redundancy round opening at the publisher.

Guardian owner appears to be pressing on with plan to sell Observer to Tortoise Media.

The post Scott Trust says ‘talks continue to progress’ over Observer sale to Tortoise appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
A picture of the offices of The Guardian and Observer, illustrating a story about voluntary redundancy round opening at the publisher.

The Guardian-owning Scott Trust appears to be pressing ahead with plans to sell The Observer to Tortoise Media.

The 12-person board of the Trust, which is a non-profit-making company, met on Monday 25 November to discuss a bid made by Tortoise Media to acquire The Observer.

Tortoise has funding of £20m to invest in turning the Observer into a standalone newspaper with a paywalled website.

Following yesterday’s all-day meeting of the Trust a spokesperson said: “Today the Scott Trust met to discuss the potential sale of the Observer and the proposed terms.

“Talks continue to progress and there are a few outstanding points. All parties will continue detailed discussions to ensure the proposed agreement is the best it can be for staff, readers and the future of liberal journalism.”

The Trust has said it may keep a stake in The Observer after its sale to Tortoise and the Financial Times has reported that it may also offer additional investment in the new Tortoise/Observer business.

The ongoing talks mean strike action in protest at the Observer-Tortoise deal is still set to go ahead with the first 48-hour strike from Guardian and Observer journalists set to take place on Wednesday 4 December.

The Scott Trust has been sent a series of questions about the Observer deal by a consortium of press freedom groups which has asked for written answers.

These include: “Why is the sale of The Observer being discussed only with one preferred bidder instead of through an open, transparent and fair process?”

And: “What is the Scott Trust’s responsibility if this [the Tortoise Media] plan fails?”

The 70 Observer journalists who would transfer across to Tortoise have concerns about job security and editorial independence.

Tortoise Media said yesterday: “We want to save The Observer, both for today’s readers and the generation to come. We have heard from a lot of Observer journalists who are excited about our ambition for the paper – and the people we bring with digital skills in podcasts, data journalism and newsletters, the investment that means new staff jobs, a much bigger editorial budget and a real plan for growth.

“We believe we can strengthen liberal journalism, adding to the range and reach of progressive voices; we can enable The Observer to reach new readers, as a Sunday newspaper with a digital life of its own; and we can renew the paper as a powerful voice in the world.”

The post Scott Trust says ‘talks continue to progress’ over Observer sale to Tortoise appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Observer sale to Tortoise: Press freedom groups seeks answers from Scott Trust https://pressgazette.co.uk/publishers/nationals/observer-sale-press-freedom/ Mon, 25 Nov 2024 11:32:29 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=234279 Montage: Tortoise founder James Harding, Observer front page, Guardian and Observer offices, Scott Trust chair Ole Jacob Sunde

Questions asked include: why is there only one bidder, and why can't staff speak out freely?

The post Observer sale to Tortoise: Press freedom groups seeks answers from Scott Trust appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Montage: Tortoise founder James Harding, Observer front page, Guardian and Observer offices, Scott Trust chair Ole Jacob Sunde

The chair of the Scott Trust has offered to meet a consortium of press freedom groups which has raised concerns over the sale of The Observer.

The board of the Trust, a limited company which owns Guardian Media Group, was expected to meet on Monday 25 November, to discuss proposals to sell The Observer to Tortoise Media.

With Guardian and Observer journalists set to hold a 48-hour strike on 4 December in protest at the deal, the Trust is under pressure to make a decision.

The Scott Trust has received a letter co-signed by the European Centre for Press and Media Freedom, the European Federation of Journalists, Index on Censorship, International Press Institute and OBC Transeuropa demanding answers to six key questions about the sale of The Observer.

Tortoise Media is believed to have funding of £20m to invest in turning The Observer into a stand-alone newspaper and paywalled website. According to the FT, The Scott Trust may also provide additional investment in the deal and the body has already said it plans to retain a stake in The Observer.

The letter sent by the press freedom groups to the Trust and Tortoise Media asks the following questions:

“The Observer is the leading liberal, progressive Sunday newspaper in the UK. Given the Scott Trust’s commitment to safeguarding freedom of the press and liberal journalism, what protections will be included in any deal to protect its editorial independence?

“What safeguards regarding future ownership will be written into the sale?”

The groups also asked a question about whether the Trust has properly vetted all the potential investors, including looking at foreign business links.

The letter says: “Individuals we spoke to described Tortoise’s business plan as ‘unconvincing’ and ‘seriously under-financed’. What is the Scott Trust’s responsibility if this plan fails? Are any safeguards being included in the deal?

“Why is the sale of The Observer being discussed only with one preferred bidder instead of through an open, transparent and fair process?

“Will you allow Observer and Guardian staff to speak out freely about the impact of the deal on press freedom and UK media plurality without fear of sanction or recrimination? At present, they report being unable to voice their opinions freely or have been warned against doing so.”

Scott Trust chair Ole Jacob Sunde has written back to the groups saying: “Thank you for your letter and the questions that you raise. We will happily respond to your points. Perhaps, in the first instance, we could arrange a call so I can better understand your concerns.

“As you will know, The Guardian has been a partner to your organisations on various vital journalistic endeavours – including the anti-SLAPPS coalition. We hope you know us to share values on many areas in the media landscape.

“We take our obligations to safeguarding the future of liberal journalism very seriously and would welcome you sharing more about where you believe there’s misalignment.”

Press Gazette understands the groups have asked for written answers and cannot offer a meeting until early December.

Observer journalist Carole Cadwalladr has been told by Guardian management that her public statements about the proposed Observer deal may be in breach of her contract and has been ask to “desist” from saying anything publicly which brings Guardian News and Media “into disrepute”.

Cadwalladr was the keynote speaker on Friday 23 November at a Malta conference on media freedom run by the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe during which she denounced the sale of The Observer to Tortoise as an “existential threat to our journalism”.

A spokesperson for Tortoise Media said: “We want to save The Observer, both for today’s readers and the generation to come. We have heard from a lot of Observer journalists who are excited about our ambition for the paper – and the people we bring with digital skills in podcasts, data journalism and newsletters, the investment that means new staff jobs, a much bigger editorial budget and a real plan for growth.

“We believe we can strengthen liberal journalism, adding to the range and reach of progressive voices; we can enable The Observer to reach new readers, as a Sunday newspaper with a digital life of its own; and we can renew the paper as a powerful voice in the world.”

On the subject of the letter, Tortoise said: “We have not received a letter from these bodies, but we are happy to provide assurances on editorial independence. All of our investors are fully committed to the robust principles of editorial freedom that are enshrined in our articles of association and overseen by an independent editorial board chaired by former FT editor Richard Lambert.”

The post Observer sale to Tortoise: Press freedom groups seeks answers from Scott Trust appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Observer writer speaks out over ‘grave threat’ to title at press freedom conference https://pressgazette.co.uk/publishers/carole-cadwalladr-observer-tortoise-defies-warnings-management/ Fri, 22 Nov 2024 14:43:09 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=234254 Observer journalist Carole Cadwalladr, who has revealed she has been warned off criticising a proposed deal to sell her paper to Tortoise Media by management at Guardian News and Media

Observer writer Carole Cadwalladr has been told to "desist" by management after public statements about Tortoise deal.

The post Observer writer speaks out over ‘grave threat’ to title at press freedom conference appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Observer journalist Carole Cadwalladr, who has revealed she has been warned off criticising a proposed deal to sell her paper to Tortoise Media by management at Guardian News and Media

Observer writer Carole Cadwalladr has denounced plans to sell the title to Tortoise Media at an international conference on press freedom – despite being told to “desist” by management after previous public statements about the deal

Cadwalladr is one of few serving Guardian or Observer journalists to have spoken out publicly about the proposal to transfer the title and its 70 staff to Tortoise Media despite widespread opposition. Some 93% of Guardian and Observer journalists voted in favour of strike action in protest at the deal this week.

The podcast publisher says it has £20m to invest in turning The Observer into a standalone newspaper with a paywalled website. But Cadwalladr and many other Guardian staff feel the deal puts the future of the title in jeopardy.

Cadwalladr, who is on a freelance contract with The Observer, was written to by management after appearing on the Media Confidential podcast hosted by former Guardian editor Alan Rusbridger earlier this month.

Press Gazette understands she has been accused of disparaging colleagues and the company and of making inaccurate statements. Cadwalladr said she denies disparaging anyone and said no detail has been given about alleged inaccuracies.

All Observer and Guardian journalists are required to adhere to the GNM editorial code which states: “It is important that outside interests do not come into conflict with journalists’ work for GNM in any way that could compromise, or appear to compromise, the editorial integrity and reputation of individual journalists or GNM”. Freelance contributors are required to sign a contract which states: “You shall not at any time do anything to bring GNM’s brands, trademarks or reputation into disrepute”.

Cadwalladr was told that it was third occasion she had breached company ruleswith recent public statements and been asked to “desist”.

But Cadwalladr told Press Gazette: “I’ve decided that my loyalty lies with the readers of The Observer.”

Cadwalladr was the keynote speaker today (Friday 22 November) at a Malta conference on media freedom run by the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe.

New age of ‘politically motivated witch hunts’

She warned that the US “is entering a new age of politically motivated witch hunts that will look like McCarthyism on steroids” in her address.

And she spoke about her legal fight with political donor Arron Banks which left her with a £1.2m costs bill.

She said: “The biggest political donor in UK history didn’t sue the Guardian, instead, he came after me as an individual. He waited for me to repeat a line from a Guardian article in a talk, and he sued me for that.

“It was clever and deliberate and designed to silence and intimidate me. To isolate me from my news organisation. And to silence and intimidate all journalism into him. And it worked.

“And this, I have no doubt, is a playbook that will be deployed against other journalists.

“It wasn’t just that the lawsuit tied me up for years in litigation and led to years of stress and fear, it also became a central weapon in an online harassment and abuse campaign against me. Every court report led to a new wave of attacks. It was like being trapped in a washing machine, a spin cycle of abuse.”

‘Grave threat’ warning over Observer deal

And she went on to tell the conference that her own news organisation “is under grave threat”.

She said: “All of mine and my colleagues’ work is read by a global audience on the Guardian’s website. But in the UK, it also appears in the print edition of The Observer, The Guardian’s Sunday sister newspaper.

“And, as we speak, The Guardian’s board has approved the sale of The Observer – the oldest Sunday newspaper in the world – to a tiny, financially unprofitable podcast company.

“We, the journalists of both The Guardian and The Observer, believe that this is an existential threat to our journalism.

“We believe the company that is seeking to buy us has no track record of success, no business model and insufficient funds. We don’t understand why no alternatives have been considered. We believe that The Guardian is risking the trust of the readers by making such a reckless decision in haste. We believe it is the beginning of the end of our newspaper.

“Now, 93% of us have voted to go on strike.

“I’m telling you this because ownership matters. The British government has previously scrutinised the potential buyers of news organisations and I urge it do so in this case.

“Because the freedom of the press is precious and fragile and when a news organisation dies, it leaves a gaping hole. Politicians go unscrutinised, crimes go unreported, human rights abuses go undocumented.

“If press freedom means anything, it has to mean the ability to speak out to advocate for the survival of our own news organisation. Because if a newspaper is allowed to die, it’s never coming back.

“And at this point, we, the journalists of The Guardian and Observer, believe The Guardian’s management is an active threat to press freedom.

“I’m speaking on behalf of those journalists when I say that we believe its actions are imperilling the survival of a 240-year-old newspaper.”

The Scott Trust, which owns Guardian Media Group, is expected to make a decision in principle over selling The Observer on Monday,

A Guardian spokesperson said: “We recognise the strength of feeling about the proposed sale of the Observer. Our priority is to serve our readers, protect jobs and support our staff, so that the Guardian and the Observer can continue to promote liberal journalism and thrive in a challenging media environment.”

Concluding her speech, Cadwalladr said: “I’ve learned the hard way what happens when journalism comes under attack. I am lucky. I live in a country with strong institutions and rule of law. I faced a civil not a criminal suit. And it still felt like an existential struggle for survival. I’m only now two years on, recovering my psychological and physical health. And I’m ending by telling you this because there is a global witch hunt coming. And what happened to me must not be allowed to happen to other journalists.

“I am just one person. But what I worry is that news organisations will find reasons to not provide financial and other support to their journalists when they come under attack. They will be afraid of the consequences. They will find loopholes and excuses to not do the right thing.

“This is what happened to me. I faced my nightmare alone. But we cannot let that happen to other journalists. Because a threat to one journalist is a threat to all. A threat to one news organisation is a threat to all.

“There is a curtain of darkness that is falling across the world, a blanket of fake news and lies is smothering the truth and we know where that leads. We simply cannot afford to let this happen.”

A source close to The Guardian said: “Carole is a fantastic campaigning journalist and welcome to an opinion but many would respectfully disagree with her that this deal threatens the future of this business – what this about is enabling the Observer to thrive.”

The post Observer writer speaks out over ‘grave threat’ to title at press freedom conference appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Jay Rayner leaves Observer as departing editor slams planned sale https://pressgazette.co.uk/the-wire/media-jobs-uk-news/jay-rayner-observer-financial-times/ Thu, 21 Nov 2024 20:16:56 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=234227

Rayner leaves The Observer after 25 years amid a battle over its future ownership.

The post Jay Rayner leaves Observer as departing editor slams planned sale appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>

Jay Rayner, one of The Observer’s most prominent writers, is leaving the newsbrand as controversy surrounds its proposed sale to Tortoise Media.

The news was announced on the same day that Paul Webster, who was editor of The Observer until earlier this month, wrote a lengthy denunciation of the proposed sale, which he said was based on “two false premises”: that the newspaper’s operation poses a financial risk to The Guardian and that Tortoise Media could sustain the brand in print.

A Guardian and Observer staff strike over the proposed sale is set for early next month.

Rayner, who has reviewed restaurants for The Observer for 25 years, said last month that he had been shortlisted for columnist of the year in the BSME Awards “in the same month that The Guardian has told me they will terminate all our contracts if they can sell The Observer to Tortoise”.

Tortoise and Guardian News and Media have previously assured Observer staff that their jobs will be safe if the sale goes ahead.

A spokesperson for Tortoise told Press Gazette contract arrangements like Rayner’s would also be honoured in any deal.

Rayner was previously a vocal campaigner against an unsuccessful bid to merge The Observer into The Guardian in 2008.

A spokesperson for Guardian News and Media said: “Jay Rayner has entertained readers for many years with his writing and we wish him all the best with his new role.”

On Thursday, Webster, who edited The Observer for six years and was its deputy editor for 22 years, spoke out about the proposed Tortoise deal for the first time.

He wrote on Twitter: “Here’s why I think the proposed sale of the Observer to Tortoise would severely damage the reputation of the Scott Trust and threaten the future of the world’s oldest Sunday newspaper, which I edited until last weekend.

“This planned sale, if ratified by the Trust, would be a discreditable conclusion to a damaging episode in the company’s history.

“It is based on two false premises. One, that the Observer represents a serious threat to the security and future of the Guardian because of its financial position.

“This is preposterous. As editor for the past 6 years, I was provided with  revenue and expenditure data.

“They showed that despite the well-documented decline of print sales, The Observer has continued to make a net contribution of several millions of pounds to the company’s finances.

“Even once added expenses are included, as they have been in the company’s recent shameful attempt to bundle the paper out of the door as quickly as possible, and account is taken of shared resources we use, the losses are miniscule set against the company’s  £1.3bn cash pile.

“And they fail to take any account of mitigating strategies we might have discussed, but which the Trust entirely failed to consider during my tenure, or of the considerable contribution Observer journalism makes to the Guardian website’s breadth of coverage and income.

“The second false premise is that Tortoise Media, a small historically loss making start up, is able to sustain the Observer as a serious competitor on Sunday newstands.

“Based on the little information Observer journalists have been provided with it does not have the resources to shoulder the cost of sustaining a standalone Sunday paper with a comprehensive news, foreign, sports, business and cultural coverage able to compete with our rivals.

“Nor are its projections of subscription sales realistic, and uncertainty clouds the scale and future of its funding.

“The Scott Trust boasts a proud record of defending liberal journalism, as represented by both the Guardian AND the Observer. It appears as if it’s about to betray that record by essentially gifting the Observer to a small, historically loss-making start-up.

“If its losses are severe enough to warrant abandoning the Observer then it is doubtful that Tortoise has the means to sustain the title. If they are not, then the Trust, with a £1.3bn endowment, is a far better home for the Observer.

“The Guardian persistently boasts that it’s not owned by a proprietor. But – by excluding its own journalists from the process of the sale – it has behaved as if it is.

“As a senior journalist on the Guardian and Observer for 35  years, I believe the Scott Trust should reject this deal and embark on a proper review of the Observer’s future if it is to uphold its clearly enunciated role as a defender of liberal journalism at home and abroad.”

Financial Times to expand weekend food and drink coverage

The Financial Times poached Rayner amid an expansion of its weekend food and drink coverage.

The business paper has also hired former Sunday Times restaurant critic and current Noble Rot contributing editor Marina O’Loughlin for a monthly FT Magazine column about the global restaurant scene and food culture.

The FT’s current restaurant critic, Tim Hayward, moves to a new role as a food writer, “contributing deep-dives on home cooking projects and other culinary fixations”.

Rayner said: “I have been both an avid fan and devoted reader of the paper for many years and it’s an honour to become part of a team I have admired from afar for so long.

“I can’t wait to play my part alongside the huge talents that are Jancis Robinson, Tim Hayward and Marina O’Loughlin, in providing the most entertaining and authoritative food and drink coverage in the business.”

Hayward said: “Twelve years is a long time to be critical about restaurants. I’m looking forward to being able to write fully about the thing I love, enthusing about food, in breadth and depth.”

And O’Loughlin said that, “after leaving the Sunday Times, I’ve made a hobby of saying ‘no’ to offers.

“So it’s with enormous pleasure that I’m now saying ‘yes’ to my favourite of all the major newspapers, with the best food and drink section in the business.”

Janine Gibson, editor of FT Weekend, said: “The FT Magazine’s food and drink coverage under its brilliant editor Harriet Fitch Little has gone from strength to strength.

“We have ambitious and exciting plans for the next year and assembling this stellar lineup of the greatest authorities in their field is the first step.

“FT Weekend readers look to us for expertise and exceptional writing on every aspect of culture, and this food and drink team will be unparalleled in their ability to deliver on every front.”

The post Jay Rayner leaves Observer as departing editor slams planned sale appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Guardian CEO warns staff Observer faces ‘difficult decisions’ if Tortoise deal fails https://pressgazette.co.uk/publishers/nationals/observer-sale-latest/ Thu, 31 Oct 2024 16:40:21 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=233545 Guardian News & Media chief executive Anna Bateson. Picture: Guardian News & Media

Anna Bateson says Observer is loss-making but has chance to be sustainable with Tortoise.

The post Guardian CEO warns staff Observer faces ‘difficult decisions’ if Tortoise deal fails appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Guardian News & Media chief executive Anna Bateson. Picture: Guardian News & Media

Observer staff have been warned that “difficult decisions” lie ahead if the Tortoise deal to buy the title does not go ahead, according to the latest sale update.

Guardian Media Group chief executive Anna Bateson said The Observer is loss-making when shared costs are taken into account and that it is forecast to become loss-making regardless within three years.

According to a financial statement for the year to August 2024, the Observer newspaper made annual revenue of £16.4m meaning it made a “contribution” to GMG of £3.4m, excluding shared costs.

In her email to staff, Bateson said GMG was already “beginning to think about the future of the title, given its financial situation and the fact it is a UK-only, Sunday print newspaper” before Tortoise Media made its bid for the title just over a month ago.

Tortoise Media has promised £25m of investment in The Observer over five years. No additional purchase price has yet been mentioned publicly.

Bateson described this as “a serious offer” which would “create a more sustainable business strategy for The Observer”.

Sale latest: The Observer would become main Tortoise Media brand

Talking about the detail of the Tortoise bid, she said: “Tortoise Media propose that they would continue to publish the Observer as a Sunday newspaper, with business, sport and international coverage and an emphasis on original journalism.

“The Observer would be the brand for the media organisation and all the existing sections – Observer Magazine, New Review and OFM [Observer Food Monthly] – would be retained. In addition, Tortoise would invest in creating a dedicated digital presence for the Observer, as well as newsletters, podcasts and events.”

Observer insiders question whether Tortoise has the funding in place to cover business, sport and international news – all of which currently come from Guardian journalists.

Bateson said a final decision on whether or not the deal will go ahead is expected before Christmas. Insiders question why there is such haste to get the deal done to what appears to be a Tortoise-imposed deadline.

The Scott Trust, which owns The Guardian, has been accused of betraying The Observer and its journalists by seeking to sell the title.

But Bateson said: “If the deal goes ahead, ensuring that there will be an ongoing alignment of values is extremely important. The Scott Trust believes that considering the offer is entirely consistent with its responsibilities to liberal journalism.

“The Observer would become the sole title and focus for Tortoise, thus enhancing liberal journalism and increasing plurality.”

Insiders maintain that statements from The Scott Trust had given the impression that The Observer was subject to the same protections as The Guardian. For example at the time of its purchase in 1993 then-Scott Trust chair Hugo Young said The Guardian’s “trust safeguards will be fully extended to The Observer”, although management believe this related only to the newspaper’s editorial independence.

Observer staff warned status quo will not return

Bateson warned that life would not go on as before for Observer staff if the Tortoise deal is abandoned.

She said: “If the deal does not go ahead, the status quo is not an option. Kath [Viner, The Guardian editor], in her email at the beginning of the summer, committed to a strategic audit of the Observer which would involve some difficult choices – and that would need to happen urgently.

“We want to be plain about this because we all have a responsibility to be honest about the growth prospects of a UK only, Sunday, print title when it is competing with investment in the future of the Guardian.”

One Observer insider said the title was no more print-only than the The Guardian given the fact all its content was published online and contributed to the digital side of the business.

On the Observer’s current financial position, Bateson said: “We have shared an Observer-only P&L (profit and loss statement) with staff. Although the Observer has performed well in terms of its market share, its circulation is, like all newspapers in print, in continual decline and the title is forecast to be loss-making within three years, if not sooner.

“If shared costs, such as technology, ad sales, marketing, rent, finance and HR as well as sport, international and business journalism, were allocated, the Observer would already be loss-making.

“This is why we talk about needing to make difficult decisions if the deal does not go ahead. In other words, the Observer is likely to have more freedom to be financially sustainable if it is separated from the Guardian.”

One insider said that the tone of this felt “quite bullying” because it was effectively telling Observer staff “things will be horrible if you stay”.

It is still unknown who exactly is financially backing the deal, but Bateson said: “An initial assessment of Tortoise Media’s existing investors found them fit and proper to proceed to this point.”

Tortoise editor in chief James Harding is the largest single shareholder in the business with a 32.5% stake.

Scott Trust would retain Observer stake

If the deal goes ahead, the Scott Trust will retain a small stake in The Observer which would be “a sign of confidence in the future success of the title”, Bateson said.

The Observer would be covered, she said, by Tortoise Media’s existing commitments to editorial independence.

The existing NUJ “house agreement” would transfer across with The Observer. This means staff would be protected from compulsory redundancies (but not from losing their jobs if the standalone business were to fail).

Journalists at The Guardian and Observer have backed possible strike action in protest against the sale in an indicative vote.

The post Guardian CEO warns staff Observer faces ‘difficult decisions’ if Tortoise deal fails appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Guardian Media Group journalists back strike in indicative vote on Tortoise Observer bid https://pressgazette.co.uk/publishers/nationals/guardian-observer-strike-indicative-ballot-tortoise/ Fri, 25 Oct 2024 16:34:45 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=233421 Observer front page, October 2024, illustrating news that Guardian and Observer journalists have overwhelmingly voted in favour of a strike in an indicative ballot.

The NUJ said "journalists are resolute in their opposition to the Observer sale".

The post Guardian Media Group journalists back strike in indicative vote on Tortoise Observer bid appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Observer front page, October 2024, illustrating news that Guardian and Observer journalists have overwhelmingly voted in favour of a strike in an indicative ballot.

Guardian and Observer journalists have voted in favour of possible strike action in protest at proposals to sell The Observer to Tortoise Media.

The combined NUJ chapel has already passed a no-confidence motion in the board of the Scott Trust in protest at the Observer sale plan.

According to the NUJ, an “overwhelming” 93% of the group’s journalists, on a turnout of 70%, indicated their willingness to take strike action and 96% voted in favour of action short of a strike.

The union says it has now informed GMG of its intention to formally ballot members for industrial action.

The union said: “The resounding decision is in opposition to the proposed sale of The Observer and follows confirmation by the Guardian Media Group last month that it is engaged in exclusive talks with Tortoise Media.”

At a meeting of the NUJ Guardian & Observer chapel on 24 October, representatives agreed a formal postal ballot process should now proceed, with journalists urged to vote yes to participating in industrial action.

According to the NUJ: “Journalists are agreed that they have no choice but to consider industrial action to protect the much-loved title and its role providing valued journalism within the media landscape.

“No engagement with journalists or the NUJ was sought prior to negotiations by GMG and the union has voiced its deep-rooted concerns over the viability of the title and journalists’ jobs if it is sold to James Harding’s startup. The company, not yet profitable, has pledged £20m capital investment with plans to implement a paywall if the bid is accepted.”

NUJ general secretary Michelle Stanistreet said: “Journalists are resolute in their opposition to the Observer sale for reasons understood by its readers, many of whom have indicated their support for members.

“The hurried decision to pursue talks without prior engagement with the very journalists who ensure the title’s success is shocking and ill-judged, but reps are committed to resolving the dispute and stress there is still time to avoid industrial action. There must now be an end to transfer talks and a willingness by the Scott Trust to demonstrate its commitment to the Observer.”

A spokesperson for Guardian News and Media said: “Guardian Media Group announced last month that it was entering into exclusive negotiations about the offer from Tortoise Media to buy the Observer. We were transparent about the offer so we could openly engage with Observer staff and we will continue to do so. The offer proposes an investment in the future of the Observer, including building a digital presence for the Sunday newspaper, and those negotiations are ongoing.”

Earlier this week former Observer editor Roger Alton gave his blessing to the Tortoise Media bid.

He said: “Clearly the Scott Trust, owners of the Guardian, wants to wash its hands of the Obs, which it has always seemed to view as an unwanted and charismatic neighbour arriving at a sedate family dinner. In my view, Tortoise would clearly be an ideal new owner. It too has a proud record in major campaigns, its journalism is widely admired, its podcasts pioneering too.”

The post Guardian Media Group journalists back strike in indicative vote on Tortoise Observer bid appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
British Journalism Awards 2024: Full list of this year’s finalists https://pressgazette.co.uk/press-gazette-events/british-journalism-awards-2024-full-list-of-this-years-finalists/ Thu, 24 Oct 2024 12:45:15 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=233270

The full shortlist for the British Journalism Awards 2024, with links to the nominated work.

The post British Journalism Awards 2024: Full list of this year’s finalists appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>

Press Gazette is honoured to announce the finalists for the British Journalism Awards 2024.

This year’s British Journalism Awards attracted 750 entries encompassing every major news organisation in the UK.

The finalists are announced today following a three-week process involving 80 independent judges and two days of jury-style meetings.

In order to make the shortlists work has to be revelatory, show journalistic skill and rigour and serve the public interest.

The winners will be announced on 12 December at a dinner in London hosted by Radio 2 presenter and journalist Jeremy Vine.

Details here about how to book tickets.

The shortlist for News Provider of the Year will be announced following a second round of judging. The winners of Journalist of the Year, the Marie Colvin Award and the Public Service prize will be announced on the night.

Chairman of judges and Press Gazette editor-in-chief Dominic Ponsford said: “Without journalism, Boris Johnson would still be prime minister, wronged postmasters would not have a voice and victims of the infected blood scandal would not have a chance of compensation.

“The 2024 British Journalism Awards shortlists celebrate the stories which would not be told without journalists willing to shine a light on uncomfortable truths and publications brave enough to back them up.

“Congratulations to all our finalists and thank you to everyone who took the time to enter the British Journalism Awards.

“In a media world which is increasingly controlled by a few parasitic technology platforms it is more important than ever to celebrate the publishers willing to invest in and support quality journalism that makes a difference for the better in our world.”

British Journalism Awards 2024 shortlist in full:

Social Affairs, Diversity & Inclusion Journalism

Natasha Cox, Ahmed El Shamy, Rosie Garthwaite — BBC Eye Investigations

Jessica Hill — Schools Week

Sasha Baker, Valeria Rocca — The Bureau of Investigative Journalism

Rianna Croxford, Ruth Evans, Cate Brown, Ed McGown, Tom Stone, Ed Campbell, Karen Wightman — BBC Panorama

Daniel Hewitt, Imogen Barrer, Mariah Cooper, Reshma Rumsey — ITV News

Louise Tickle — Tortoise Media

Abi Kay — Farmers Weekly

Joshua Nelken-Zitser, Ida Reihani, Kit Gillet — Business Insider

Features Journalism

Sophie Elmhirst — 1843 magazine, The Economist and The Guardian

Jenny Kleeman The Guardian

Sirin Kale — The Guardian

Zoe Beaty — The Independent

Inderdeep Bains — Daily Mail

David James Smith — The Independent

Fiona Hamilton — The Times

Barbara McMahon — Daily Mail

Local Journalism

Abi Whistance, Joshi Herrmann, Kate Knowles, Mollie Simpson, Jothi Gupta — Mill Media

Richard Newman, Jennifer O’Leary, Gwyneth Jones, Chris Thornton — BBC Spotlight

Sam McBride — Belfast Telegraph

Chris Burn — The Yorkshire Post

Jane Haynes — Birmingham Mail and Birmingham Mail/Post

Wendy Robertson — The Bridge

Health & Life Sciences Journalism

Rebecca Thomas — The Independent

Fin Johnston — The Bureau of Investigative Journalism

Hannah Barnes — The New Statesman

Robbie Boyd, Eamonn Matthews, Steve Grandison, Ian Bendelow, Sophie Borland, Katie O’Toole, Islay Stacey, Ali Watt, Frances Peters — Quicksilver Media for Channel 4 Dispatches

Ellie Pitt, Cree Haughton, Justina Simpson, Ellie Swinton, Patrick Russell, Liam Ayers — ITV News

Martin Bagot — Daily Mirror

Hanna Geissler — Daily Express

Sue Mitchell, Rob Lawrie, Joel Moors, Winifred Robinson, Dan Clarke, Philip Sellars, Tom Brignell, Mom Tudie — BBC

Gabriel Pogrund, Katie Tarrant — The Sunday Times

Mike Sullivan, Jerome Starkey, Mike Ridley — The Sun

Hannah Summers — The Bureau of Investigative Journalism

Rianna Croxford, Ruth Evans — BBC Panorama and BBC News

Isobel Yeung, Alex Nott, Esme Ash, Nick Parnes, Alistair Jackson, Matt Bardo, Sarah Wilson — Channel 4 Dispatches

Comment Journalism

Daniel Finkelstein — The Times

Matthew Syed — The Sunday Times

Will Hayward — WalesOnline/The Will Hayward Newsletter

Kitty Donaldson — i

Frances Ryan — The Guardian

Duncan Robinson — The Economist

Specialist Journalism

Peter Blackburn — The Doctor (by the British Medical Association)

Lucinda Rouse, Emily Burt, Ollie Peart, Louise Hill, David Robinson, Rebecca Cooney, Andy Ricketts, Nav Pal, Til Owen — Third Sector

Lucie Heath — i

Deborah Cohen, Margaret McCartney — BMJ/Pharmaceutical Journal

Lee Mottershead — Racing Post

Jessica Hill — Schools Week

Emily Townsend — Health Service Journal

Roya Nikkhah — The Sunday Times

Foreign Affairs Journalism

Christina Lamb — The Sunday Times

Alex Crawford — Sky News

Kim Sengupta — The Independent

Vanessa Bowles, Jaber Badwan — Channel 4 Dispatches

Louise Callaghan — The Sunday Times

Secunder Kermani — Channel 4 News

Gesbeen Mohammad, Brad Manning, Nechirvan Mando, Ghoncheh Habibiazad, Esella Hawkey, Tom Giles, Hafez — ITV

Stuart Ramsay, Dominique van Heerden, Toby Nash — Sky News

Arkady Ostrovsky — 1843 magazine, The Economist

Technology Journalism, sponsored by Amazon

Alexander Martin — The Record from Recorded Future News

Marianna Spring — BBC News

Joe Tidy — BBC World Service

Amanda Chicago Lewis — 1843 magazine, The Economist

Cathy Newman, Job Rabkin, Emily Roe, Sophie Braybrook, Guy Basnett, Ed Howker — Channel 4 News

Helen Lewis — BBC Radio 4/BBC Sounds

Energy & Environment Journalism, sponsored by Renewable UK

Sam McBride — Belfast Telegraph

Josephine Moulds — The Bureau of Investigative Journalism

Esme Stallard, Becky Dale, Sophie Woodcock, Jonah Fisher, Libby Rogers — BBC News

Rachel Salvidge, Leana Hosea — The Guardian/Watershed

Guy Grandjean, Patrick Fee, Gwyneth Jones, Chris Thornton — BBC Spotlight Northern Ireland

Sofia Quaglia — The Guardian

Jess Staufenberg — SourceMaterial

Arts & Entertainment Journalism

Mark Daly, Mona McAlinden, Shelley Jofre, Jax Sinclair, Karen Wightman, Hayley Hassall — BBC Panorama

Jonathan Dean — The Times and The Sunday Times

Rachael Healy — The Guardian and Observer

Tom Bryant — Daily Mirror

Lucy Osborne, Stephanie Kirchgaessner — The Guardian and Observer

Clemmie Moodie, Hannah Hope, Scarlet Howes — The Sun

Carolyn Atkinson, Olivia Skinner — BBC Radio 4 Front Row

Rosamund Urwin, Charlotte Wace — The Times and The Sunday Times

New Journalist of the Year

Rafe Uddin — Financial Times

Sammy Gecsoyler — The Guardian

Kaf Okpattah — ITV News, ITV News London

Simar Bajaj — The Guardian, New Scientist

Nimra Shahid — The Bureau of Investigative Journalism

Venetia Menzies — The Sunday Times

Oliver Marsden — The Sunday Times/Al Jazeera

Yasmin Rufo — BBC News

Sports Journalism

Jacob Whitehead — The Athletic

Oliver Brown — The Telegraph

Simon Lock, Rob Davies, Jacob Steinberg — The Bureau of Investigative Journalism / The Guardian

Jacob Judah — 1843 magazine, The Economist

Riath Al-Samarrai — Daily Mail

Ian Herbert — Daily Mail

Matt Lawton — The Times

Um-E-Aymen Babar — Sky Sports

Campaign of the Year

Caroline Wheeler —The Sunday Times: Bloody Disgrace

Patrick Butler, Josh Halliday, John Domokos — The Guardian: Unpaid Carers

Computer Weekly editorial team — Computer Weekly: Post Office Scandal

David Cohen — Evening Standard: Show Respect

Lucie Heath — i: Save Britain’s Rivers

Hanna Geissler, Giles Sheldrick — Daily Express: Give Us Our Last Rights

Amy Clare Martin — The Independent: IPP Jail Sentences

Martin Bagot, Jason Beattie — Daily Mirror: Save NHS Dentistry

Photojournalism

Thomas Dworzak — 1843 magazine, The Economist

A holiday camp on the shore of Lake Sevan in Armenia, photographed by Thomas Dworzak for 1843. Picture: Thomas Dworzak/Magnum Photos for 1843/The Economist

André Luís Alves — 1843 magazine, The Economist

Fans attend the concert of a local band in Kharkiv, Ukraine. Picture: André Luís Alves for 1843 magazine/The Economist

Giles Clarke — CNN Digital

Gang leader Jimmy “Barbecue” Cherizier poses for a picture with gang members in Port-au-Prince, Haiti in the immediate days preceding the gang takeover of the capital. Picture: Giles Clarke for CNN

Nichole Sobecki — 1843 magazine, The Economist

A woman appears in the featured image for an 1843 magazine article titled “How poor Kenyans became economists’ guinea pigs”. Picture: Nichole Sobecki for 1843 Magazine/The Economist

Dimitris Legakis — Athena Picture Agency

Photo of Swansea police arresting drunk man likened to Renaissance art. Picture: Dimitris Legakis/Athena Pictures via The Guardian

Stefan Rousseau — PA Media

A baby reaches toward the camera, partially blocking an image of Keir Starmer. Picture: Stefan Rousseau/PA Media, via Rousseau’s Twitter

Hannah McKay — Reuters

Britain’s King Charles wears the Imperial State Crown on the day of the State Opening of Parliament at the Palace of Westminster in London, July 17. Reuters/Hannah McKay

Interviewer of the Year

Alice Thomson — The Times

Christina Lamb — The Sunday Times

Laura Kuenssberg — Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, BBC News

Charlotte Edwardes — The Guardian

Nick Ferrari — LBC

Samantha Poling — BBC

Piers Morgan — Piers Morgan Uncensored

Paul Brand — ITV News

  • Interview with Rishi Sunak
  • Interview with Ed Davey
  • Interview with Keir Starmer

(View all three interviews here)

Politics Journalism

Jim Pickard, Anna Gross — Financial Times

Pippa Crerar — The Guardian

Rowena Mason, Henry Dyer, Matthew Weaver — The Guardian

Job Rabkin, Darshna Soni, Ed Gove, Saif Aledros, Georgina Lee, Lee Sorrell — Channel 4 News

Beth Rigby — Sky News

Caroline Wheeler — The Sunday Times

Jane Merrick — i

Steven Swinford — The Times

Business, Finance and Economics Journalism, sponsored by Starling Bank

Simon Murphy — Daily Mirror & Sunday Mirror

Ed Conway — Sky News

Tom Bergin — Reuters

Gill Plimmer, Robert Smith — Financial Times

Siddharth Philip, Benedikt Kammel, Anthony Palazzo, Katharine Gemmell, Sabah Meddings — Bloomberg News

Anna Isaac, Alex Lawson — The Guardian

Danny Fortson — The Sunday Times

Online Video Journalism

Alex Rothwell, Alastair Good, Yasmin Butt, Pauline Den Hartog Jager, Jack Feeney, Federica De Caria, Kasia Sobocinska, Stephanie Bosset — The Times and The Sunday Times

Andrew Harding — BBC News

Mohamed Ibrahim, Owen Pinnel, Mouna Ba, Wael El-Saadi, Feras Al Ajrami — BBC Eye Investigations

Tom Pettifor, Matthew Young, Daniel Dove — Daily Mirror

Lucinda Herbert, Iain Lynn — National World Video

Reem Makhoul, Robert Leslie, Clancy Morgan, Amelia Kosciulek, Matilda Hay, Liz Kraker, Dorian Barranco, Barbara Corbellini Duarte, Erica Berenstein, Yasser Abu Wazna — Business Insider

Piers Morgan — Piers Morgan Uncensored

Ben Marino, Joe Sinclair, Veronica Kan-Dapaah, Petros Gioumpasis, Greg Bobillot — Financial Times

Investigation of the Year

Scarlet Howes, Mike Hamilton, Alex West — The Sun

Rosamund Urwin, Charlotte Wace, Paul Morgan-Bentley, Esella Hawkey, Imogen Wynell Mayow, Alice McShane, Florence Kennard, Ian Bendelow, Victoria Noble, Alistair Jackson, Sarah Wilson, Geraldine McKelvie — The Sunday Times, The Times, Hardcash Productions, Channel Four Dispatches Investigations Unit

Alex Thomson, Nanette van der Laan — Channel 4 News

Paul Morgan-Bentley — The Times

Ruth Evans, Oliver Newlan, Leo Telling, Sasha Hinde, Hayley Clarke, Karen Wightman — BBC Panorama

Job Rabkin, Darshna Soni, Ed Gove, Saif Aledros, Georgina Lee, Lee Sorrell — Channel 4 News

Holly Bancroft, May Bulman, Monica C. Camacho, Fahim Abed — The Independent and Lighthouse Reports

Daniel Hewitt, Imogen Barrer, Isabel Alderson-Blench, John Ray — ITV News: The Post Office Tapes

Rowena Mason, Henry Dyer, Matthew Weaver — The Guardian

Samantha Poling, Eamon T. O Connor, Anton Ferrie, Shelley Jofre — BBC Disclosure

Scoop of the Year

Russell Brand accused of rape, sexual assaults and abuse — The Sunday Times, The Times, Hardcash Productions and Channel 4 Dispatches

A screenshot of The Times article about Russell Brand being accused of rape

Huw Edwards Huw Edwards charged with making 37 indecent images of children, ‘shared on WhatsApp’ — The Sun

The Sun's front page reporting that Huw Edwards had been charged with possessing indecent images of children

Naked photos sent in WhatsApp ‘phishing’ attacks on UK MPs and staff— Politico

No 10 pass for Labour donor who gave £500,000 — The Sunday Times

Labour will add 20% VAT to private school fees within first year of winning power — i

The Nottingham Attacks: A Search for Answers — BBC Panorama

Innovation

Harry Lewis-Irlam, Stephen Matthews, Darren Boyle, Rhodri Morgan — Mail Online: Deep Dive

Laura Dunn, Katie Lilley-Harris, Ellie Senior, Sherree Younger, Scott Nicholson, Jamie Mckerrow Maxwell — KL Magazine

Niels de Hoog, Antonio Voce, Elena Morresi, Manisha Ganguly, Ashley Kirk — The Guardian

Alison Killing, Chris Miller, Peter Andringa, Chris Campbell, Sam Learner, Sam Joiner — Financial Times

David Dubas-Fisher, Cullen Willis, Paul Gallagher, Richard Ault — Reach Data Unit

Gabriel Pogrund, Emanuele Midolo, Venetia Menzies, Darren Burchett, Narottam Medhora, Cecilia Tombesi — The Sunday Times

The post British Journalism Awards 2024: Full list of this year’s finalists appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Russell-Brand-accused-of-rape Sun-Huw-Edwards-charged Politico times-scoop-lord-alli the-i-scoop-labour-vat-private-schools BBC-Panorama-Nottingham-scoop
Tortoise is ‘ideal owner’ for Observer says former editor Roger Alton https://pressgazette.co.uk/news/tortoise-ideal-owner-for-observer-former-editor-roger-alton/ Mon, 21 Oct 2024 16:56:34 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=233280

The Scott Trust clearly wants to "wash its hands" of the Observer, writes Roger Alton.

The post Tortoise is ‘ideal owner’ for Observer says former editor Roger Alton appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>

Former Observer editor Roger Alton has given his backing to Tortoise Media‘s bid to buy his old title.

Alton was one of three former Observer editors to accuse Guardian Media Group owner the Scott Trust of abrogating its responsibilities to the title by putting it up for sale.

But writing to Press Gazette, Alton has made clear that he supports Tortoise Media’s bid. Meanwhile, the NUJ is currently balloting Guardian and Observer staff over potential strike action in protest against the deal.

The 70 Observer journalists who would transfer across to Tortoise have concerns about job security working for a stand-alone title.

Roger Alton: Tortoise would offer Observer ‘a massive new shot in the arm’

Alton writes: “I had the great privilege of editing the paper for nearly a decade from 1998 (though I had also spent a fantastic few months working there as a teenager in the 1960s, which convinced me that this was the life everybody should want, and that newspapers were the lifeblood of a healthy society).

“So I feel great loyalty and affection for the paper, which is after all the oldest Sunday paper in the world (b 1791) and has not just been responsible for some of the bravest and best campaigns of recent years, but is also a source of great fun and entertainment and some of the best writing around.

“This is why I am so cheered by the arrival of Tortoise media. Clearly the Scott Trust, owners of the Guardian, wants to wash its hands of the Obs, which it has always seemed to view as an unwanted and charismatic neighbour arriving at a sedate family dinner.

“In my view, Tortoise would clearly be an ideal new owner. It too has a proud record in major campaigns, its journalism is widely admired, its podcasts pioneering too. And it has on its staff some of the best journalists in the country. It is also utterly committed to preserving the newspaper as a print product, as well as developing a substantial digital presence.

“My belief is that Tortoise would not just be an ideal custodian of the traditions and qualities of the Observer, but would also, as a highly-skilled multi-media organisation, offer a massive new shot in the arm.”

The post Tortoise is ‘ideal owner’ for Observer says former editor Roger Alton appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Former Observer editors voice ‘profound concern’ over proposed sale of title https://pressgazette.co.uk/publishers/nationals/observer-sale-editors-letter/ Thu, 10 Oct 2024 09:33:13 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=232964 Former Observer editors Will Hutton, Roger Alton and John Mulholland

Roger Alton, John Mulholland and Will Hutton are latest to round on The Scott Trust.

The post Former Observer editors voice ‘profound concern’ over proposed sale of title appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Former Observer editors Will Hutton, Roger Alton and John Mulholland

Three former Observer editors have written to the Scott Trust expressing their “profound concern” over the proposed sale of the newspaper to Tortoise Media.

Will Hutton, Roger Alton and John Mulholland have together racked up 20 years editing the UK’s oldest Sunday newspaper.

They claim that safeguards about the Trust’s commitment to The Observer, made when it was bought in 1993, “are plainly being abrogated”.

They note that then-chair of the Scott Trust Hugo Young said at the time of the purchase: “The trust safeguards will be fully extended to The Observer, which will be edited independently of The Guardian and retain its separate character.”

The Scott Trust has owned The Guardian since 1936 when it was set up to safeguard the future of the title and protect it from death duties. The Scott Trust’s purpose, as defined in 1992, is “to secure the financial and editorial independence of The Guardian in perpetuity”.

Press Gazette understands that Guardian management believe the Hugo Young quote related to the editorial independence of The Observer, not about it being covered by the trust’s core responsibilities.

The three editors wrote that members of the Scott Trust and Guardian Media Group board may choose to “put aside” the “commitment” that was previously made to The Observer, but said: “…we would dispute that it can be done so readily and still honourably – so the reasons need to be unambiguously compelling, and the due diligence undertaken to ensure the Observer has the best prospect of surviving must be of the highest order.”

They wrote: “It has survived for close to 250 years: there is a heavy responsibility on those involved in current discussions to ensure that any decision best protects The Observer, and not just for the next five years.

“Here there are clear deficiencies. Tortoise Media’s interest in the title and belief it could quickly be made to flourish is testimony to its standing with readers and beyond.

The Observer is valuable media real estate, and an important means for ensuring liberal journalism has a significant presence on Sundays.

“Despite considerably less investment than its principal rivals, it has recently posted an increase in market share. Its presence in the Guardian group, with its distinct character, gives the group a breadth and depth it would otherwise lack as well as carrying costs that The Guardian will carry alone if the sale proceeds.”

The Observer’s current circulation is kept secret by GMG but is believed to total around 100,000.

According to a financial statement seen by Press Gazette, The Observer newspaper made a contribution of £3.4m to Guardian Media Group for the year to August 2024 if you subtract its direct revenue of £16.4m from directly-attributable costs of £13m. These figures do not include any shared Guardian resources which include: editorial, marketing, technology and office. They also don’t include any digital revenue driven by Observer journalism.

The editors have raised concerns about the sustainability of the Tortoise Media plan for The Observer.

They note: “We admire Tortoise’s journalism and respect its achievements together with its high regard for the Observer, but its promised £5m a year additional investment over five years will be significantly eaten up by the costs of underwriting the Observer’s operation as a stand-alone Sunday newspaper – unless it has other undisclosed ambitions for the title. And does Tortoise have the resource to weather unexpected uncertainties – another pandemic or geopolitical tensions?”

The letter concludes: “It is surprising that the trust and board have moved straight to a potential sale to an enterprise backed largely by venture capital whose business model is not long-term ownership but periodic exit – more likely in adverse circumstances.

“Have options for repurposing the Observer under the Trust’s ownership been considered and evaluated? What editorial and financial framework for the Observer’s continuing editorial independence and financial viability is the Trust negotiating?

“The entire exercise seems to have scant respect for earlier commitments or ongoing responsibilities to staff, readers and wider stakeholders. Surely our shared aim is as far as possible to protect The Observer’s long-standing tradition of upholding liberal values as a great Sunday paper? We are not resistant to change, but is this change the better for The Observer and even The Guardian – or worse for both?”

The Scott Trust met on Monday (7 October) but has yet to issue any response to either this letter or an open letter written by around 80 leading UK cultural figures calling on it to reject the “ill-considered” Tortoise Media offer which it described as a “betrayal”.

Separately, the joint NUJ chapel for The Guardian and Observer has passed a vote of no confidence in The Scott Trust and begun the process of balloting members to ask if they would be prepared to go on strike in protest against the deal.

One well-placed Observer source said: “The atmosphere is terrible. The Guardian management are effectively saying to us that if the Tortoise deal doesn’t go ahead then you have no future here.”

When The Observer’s future was last called into question in 2009, the senior Observer team were given the opportunity to prepare a new-look, scaled-down, lower-cost Observer which ended up performing well commercially and editorially. This time, no other options appear to be currently on the table.

A spokesperson for the Scott Trust said: “The Scott Trust believes it is right to engage with Tortoise Media over the potential sale of The Observer and negotiations are ongoing. We appreciate that it is a time of uncertainty for staff.”

The post Former Observer editors voice ‘profound concern’ over proposed sale of title appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
Leading cultural figures attack Observer sale as staff pave way for strike action https://pressgazette.co.uk/publishers/nationals/guardian-observer-staff-vote-possible-strike-tortoise-sale-plan-open-letter/ Thu, 03 Oct 2024 16:01:00 +0000 https://pressgazette.co.uk/?p=232800 A composite image showing Tortoise founder and editor James Harding at top left, the lobby for The Guardian and Observer offices in the top right and a brief opening excerpt at bottom from a new open letter from a group of cultural figures blasting Tortoise's bid to buy The Observer.

More than 70 leading UK cultural figures decry Observer sale as "a betrayal" of liberal journalism.

The post Leading cultural figures attack Observer sale as staff pave way for strike action appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>
A composite image showing Tortoise founder and editor James Harding at top left, the lobby for The Guardian and Observer offices in the top right and a brief opening excerpt at bottom from a new open letter from a group of cultural figures blasting Tortoise's bid to buy The Observer.

Guardian and Observer journalists have agreed they may take industrial action in protest at plans to sell The Observer to Tortoise Media.

The move comes as a group of prominent cultural figures, many of whom have contributed to The Observer, submitted an open letter to Press Gazette blasting the possible sale, saying it is “disastrous” and values the paper “at or near zero”.

Up to 400 staff attended a meeting of the combined Guardian and Observer NUJ chapel on Thursday (3 October) where strong feelings were aired opposing the deal.

The packed mandatory meeting went on for more than an hour and was a mixture of in-person and via Google Meet.

Two votes were passed unanimously: to put the matter “into dispute” and “if necessary” to hold “industrial action”.

The Guardian and Observer titles are owned by the Scott Trust, whose purpose is “to secure the financial and editorial independence of the Guardian in perpetuity…remaining faithful to its liberal tradition”.

Press Gazette understands staff complained about what was seen as a failure of the Trust to protect plural liberal journalism in tough times. Some spoke about a sense of “betrayal” amongst Observer journalists who have worked at the company for 30 years or more.

There was also concern raised that readers who have made financial donations in order to support Observer journalism will feel misled if the title is sold.

Mention was also made of The Guardian’s “Not For Sale” marketing campaign last year which emphasised the title’s editorial independence. Some staff at the meeting said it was ironic that in fact The Observer did seem to be for sale and apparently at a nominal price.

Guardian Media Group announced on 17 September that it was in a period of exclusive negotiations to sell The Observer to Tortoise Media, which is mainly a podcast publisher.

Tortoise founder and main shareholder James Harding has not yet revealed who is financially backing The Observer bid which is said to include £25m of investment over five years (over and above the title’s running costs). But he has assured staff that the deal will be a boost to liberal journalism.

Around 70 Observer staff would transfer over with the deal.

Both the Scott Trust and Guardian management appear keen to do the deal, with chief executive Anna Bateson describing it as “an exciting opportunity” to build The Observer and “allow The Guardian to focus on its growth strategy”.

Press Gazette understands that Harding has met with some Observer staff but there are still widespread concerns about job security if the deal goes through. Guardian and Observer journalists currently benefit from an NUJ house agreement which includes a no compulsory redundancies promise.

A Guardian spokesperson said: “We are in negotiations about the offer from Tortoise Media to buy the Observer and we are grateful to everyone who has fed their thoughts into discussions so far. One of the reasons for being transparent about the offer was so that we could openly engage with Observer staff. There is still a lot of information to work through and we will continue to discuss internally.”

Prominent cultural figures blast Tortoise bid for The Observer in open letter

Also on Thursday a group of more than 70 prominent UK cultural figures including Oscar-winning actors and directors and some of the UK’s leading novelists and playwrights addressed an open letter to the Scott Trust and Guardian Media Group describing the possible deal as “a betrayal” and calling on them “to reject this ill-considered offer at once”.

Among the signatories were actor Ralph Fiennes, musician and broadcaster Jarvis Cocker, broadcaster Carole Vorderman, playwright Tom Stoppard and actress Lesley Manville.

The letter in full:

The news that the Guardian chief executive and editor-in-chief are actively considering a takeover of the Observer by Tortoise has left us shocked and dismayed. While Tortoise is a respected media outlet, we believe that the move would be disastrous for the world’s oldest Sunday newspaper and its journalists, for the Guardian and for liberal journalism.

While figures of £100m are being bid for other publications, this poorly funded approach sets the value of the Observer at or near zero. The proposal also envisages moving it from a resilient and well-funded newspaper publisher to a small, loss-making digital startup whose funding for the takeover would in all likelihood come from private equity.

Is Tortoise really committed to continuing with the Observer in print? If it were to discontinue the newspaper or if the business were to fail, the Guardian’s editor-in-chief and chief executive and the Scott Trust, which owns Guardian Media Group, would go down in history as being responsible for the demise of the last liberal Sunday newspaper.

The immediate financial threat to the newspaper’s journalism, and its staff, is clear. Even if it were to survive, the Observer would be much changed – cut off from its network of foreign correspondents, sports reporters and business journalists. Leading writers, familiar to the paper’s readers for years, would be gone. Guardian supporters would lose the Observer’s voice and presence on the Guardian website and app. And if, as seems inevitable, the Observer’s politics, arts and culture coverage is to go behind a paywall, then its unique voice in Britain’s national conversation will be muted.

The Scott Trust, the Observer’s parent for 30 years, prides itself on providing a home for journalism free from the taint of corporate interests. Its engagement with this offer, however, suggests that the Observer’s award-winning reporting is something that the organisation, with its £1.3bn endowment, is no longer interested in protecting.

We call on Guardian Media Group and the Scott Trust to reject this ill-considered offer at once, and to retain the Observer as a key element of its seven-day print and online operation. Failure to do so would be a betrayal of the Observer, its staff and its readers.

Yours sincerely,

Monica Ali (author)

Joan Bakewell (journalist and peer)

Julian Barnes (author)

Mary Beard (classicist and broadcaster)

Frank Cottrell Boyce (screenwriter and novelist)

Rosie Boycott (journalist and peer)

Asa Butterfield (actor)

Dorothy Byrne (former television news executive)

Simon Callow (actor)

Bridget Christie (comedian)

Eliza Clark (author)

Jarvis Cocker (musician and broadcaster)

Jonathan Coe (author)

Richard Coles (author and priest)

Stephen Daldry (director and producer)

Janie Dee (actress)

Jeremy Deller (artist)

Clint Dyer (director and actor)

Richard Eyre (director)

Ralph Fiennes (actor and producer)

Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall (chef and broadcaster)

Nicole Flattery (author)

Michael Frayn (playwright and author)

Mark Gatiss (actor and director)

Bobby Gillespie (musician)

Howard Goodall (composer)

James Graham (playwright)

Hugh Grant (actor)

Colin Greenwood (musician)

Philippa Gregory (author)

Armando Iannucci (writer and producer)

Sheila Hancock (actress)

David Hare (playwright and director)

Robert Harris (author)

Jonah Hauer-King (actor)

Lord Peter Hennessy (historian and peer)

Billy Howle (actor)

Toby Jones (actor)

Asif Kapadia (filmmaker)

Jackie Kay (poet and author)

Helena Kennedy (barrister and peer)

Peter Kosminsky (writer and director)

David Kynaston (historian)

Duncan Kenworthy OBE (producer)

Daisy Lafarge (author and poet)

David Lan (playwright)

Dame Hermione Lee (biographer and academic)

Anton Lesser (actor)

Adrian Lester (actor and director)

Damian Lewis (actor)

Julian Lloyd Webber (musician)

Joe Lycett (comedian)

Caroline Lucas (politician)

Kevin MacDonald (director)

Lesley Manville (actress)

Miriam Margolyes (actress)

Eddie Marsan (actor)

Robert McCrum (author)

David Morrissey (actor and filmmaker)

Ian McEwan (author and screenwriter)

Stephen McGann (actor)

Robert Macfarlane (author and academic)

Sophie Mackintosh (author)

Sienna Miller (actress)

Abi Morgan (playwright and screenwriter)

Michael Morpurgo (author)

Blake Morrison (poet and author)

Mike Newell (director)

Bill Nighy (actor)

Megan Nolan (author)

James O’Brien (broadcaster)

Mark O’Connell (writer)

Andi Oliver (chef)

Miquita Oliver (presenter)

Michael Ondaatje (poet and writer)

Richard Ovenden (librarian and author)

Chris Packham (naturalist and broadcaster)

Pawel Pawlikowski (filmmaker)

Maxine Peake (actress)

Sarah Perry (author)

Alistair Petrie (actor)

Jonathan Pryce (actor)

Philip Pullman (author)

Steve Punt (comedian)

David Puttnam (film producer)

Mark Rylance (actor)

Michael Rosen (author)

Dominic Savage (director)

Tom Shakespeare (sociologist)

Lemn Sissay (author and broadcaster)

Gillian Slovo (author)

Delia Smith (TV presenter and cookbook writer)

Tom Stoppard (playwright and screenwriter)

Olivia Sudjic (author)

Wolfgang Tillmans (photographer)

Carol Vorderman (broadcaster)

Harriet Walter (actress)

John Ware (journalist)

Michael Wynn Jones (writer, editor and publisher)

Shoshana Zuboff (author)

Note: This list was updated on 9 October.

The post Leading cultural figures attack Observer sale as staff pave way for strike action appeared first on Press Gazette.

]]>